READ THE REVIEWS:

January 26, 2011

Cosmetic surgery — as the celebrity tabloids and society pages make clearer every day — is not always a fortunate undertaking. Under the homogenizing hands of certain doctors, a creature of eccentric charms can be made to look positively plain. This, by the way, is known to happen not only to desperate, perfection-seeking people but also to aged, overweight plays.

READ THE REVIEW
New York Daily News
BigThumbs_DOWN

Joe
Dziemianowicz

January 27, 2011

You’ve seen her: A woman with a face-lift who looks dewy from the neck up but whose crepe-y hands give away her age. So it goes with "The New York Idea," a 105-year-old play by Langdon Mitchell that’s been rehabbed for the Atlantic Theater Company by David Auburn, the Pulitzer Prize-winning author of "Proof."

READ THE REVIEW
New Jersey Newsroom
BigThumbs_DOWN

Michael
Sommers

January 25, 2011

One of the most applauded American plays of the early 1900s, Langdon Mitchell’s "The New York Idea" is a social comedy regarding divorce among impulsive, well-to-do people. Since the play was so up-to-the-minute in 1906 thought and style, the dear old thing today is a pretty if cumbersome antique that still retains considerable period charm and cleverness.

READ THE REVIEW

January 27, 2011

In 1906 — well before Noel Coward chronicled the foibles of a divorced couple still in love with another in Private Lives — Langdon Elwyn Mitchell introduced a pair of exes whose lives and emotions are inextricably entwined in The New York Idea, now being presented by the Atlantic Theater Company at the Lucille Lortel Theatre in a new adaptation by Tony Award winner David Auburn. While the production, directed by Mark Brokaw, proves uneven, there is still something satisfying about encountering a play that remains decidedly ahead of its time.

READ THE REVIEW
Curtain Up
BigThumbs_MEH

Elyse
Sommer

January 27, 2011

The Atlantic Theater Company has produced enough outstanding plays to have a loyal following of theater goers who wouldn’t miss a production, whether a premiere or a revival. This season, with their Main Stage in Chelsea undergoing renovations, they’ve soldiered on as guests in other theaters. Their last offering was a terrific double header of two Harold Pinter plays, The Collection and A Kind of Alaska at the Classic Stage’s home, The 13th Street Theater. Now, another revival, this one a comedy of manners that takes us all the way back to the first decade of the last century, is at the Lucille Lortel in the West Village usually home to MCC. It’s an adaptation of Langdon Mitchell’s 1906 The New York Idea, by David Auburn, author of the Pulitzer Prize winning Proof

READ THE REVIEW

January 24, 2011

“Marry for whim!” fumes Philip Phillimore (Michael Countryman). “The New York idea of marriage.” It also seems to be the New York idea of programming plays. Who knows why the Atlantic Theater Company chose to refurbish and remount Langdon Mitchell’s forgotten 1906 social comedy about a quartet of quarreling divorcées. (The cynical term subscriber porn comes to mind, but we’ll banish it.) David Auburn’s trim, cheeky rewrite is quite amusing, but it’s hard to shake the feeling that you’re at a superior production at the Mint, or a revival by the Roundabout—during a rare burst of unpredictable curating.

READ THE REVIEW