READ THE REVIEWS:

April 25, 2024

Thirty or so years ago, Vogel told a reporter, “I like theater that makes me feel like it’s a healing.” That’s what “Mother Play” is, a balm that comes in cardboard boxes and packing tape. It honors the dead by making them alive again and nurtures the living by providing a place to put a daughter’s love and rage. Martha’s box is not Pandora’s. It’s just another way of organizing a life.

READ THE REVIEW

April 26, 2024

Paula Vogel may be playwriting royalty, but if her latest work “Mother Play” is any indication, she has not lost sight of the instruction in the first half of her job title: play. In this new, often funny mashup between a memory play and an apartment tragedy (Vogel calls it “a play in five evictions”), the dramatist turns her typically insightful lens on her own family.

READ THE REVIEW

April 25, 2024

Still, despite its imperfections, “Mother Play” is a genuinely engaging examination of a family trying to find equilibrium. It honors the glimmers and low points of mothering and explains why, in some cases, the role is transposed onto those who were never called to it in the first place.

READ THE REVIEW

April 25, 2024

Her title, like many theatrical matriarchs, is awfully hard to live up to, which is also what Mother Play struggles to do.

READ THE REVIEW

April 25, 2024

But mostly, Mother Play feels a cold, airless, and puzzling tundra to orienteer—despite the can-this-be-happening electricity of watching Jessica Lange perform on stage.

READ THE REVIEW

April 25, 2024

Tina Landau directs. Her sure hand navigates the play’s many moods — hilarious one moment, tragic the next.

READ THE REVIEW
New York Theatre Guide
BigThumbs_UP

Allison
Considine

April 25, 2024

Mother Play is all about the mother’s touch and what it means to mother and be mothered, in all senses of the role. Martha says in the play, “There is a season for packing. And a season for unpacking.” Mother Play leaves the audience with lots to unpack.

READ THE REVIEW

April 25, 2024

Bringing decades of experience to bear, Lange is riveting—and so, by extension, is Phyllis. In this painfully honest tribute, Phyllis’s pain is part of the picture. Vogel does her mother dirty, but she does her mother proud.

READ THE REVIEW

April 25, 2024

There’s a surprising amount of levity in this dark play, and in that, author Vogel reveals a hard truth: Even terrible parents can be fun and loving sometimes, and that keeps their children coming back to them. Mother Play ends exactly as expected, but the emotional rollercoaster is worth the ride.

READ THE REVIEW
Wall Street Journal
BigThumbs_MEH

Charles
Isherwood

April 25, 2024

But while the final scene—Phyllis, in a nursing home, repeatedly wails, “I want to go home,” and fails to recognize Martha as her daughter—has a piercing sadness as Ms. Lange’s performance reaches a rending climax, too much of “Mother Play” feels evanescent, more a personal exercise in exorcising ghosts than a play that resonates on deeper levels.

READ THE REVIEW
Entertainment Weekly
BigThumbs_MEH

Christian
Holub

April 25, 2024

First of all, it feels like we could’ve taken another crack at this title. A play about a mother and her relationship to her children, and it’s just called Mother Play? There’s minimalism, and then there’s calling Moby-Dick “Whale Book.” This complaint isn’t incidental, but indicative of how the new work by esteemed playwright Paula Vogel excels in some aspects, but feels incomplete in other regards.

READ THE REVIEW
New York Daily News
BigThumbs_UP

Chris
Jones

April 25, 2024

With “Mother Play,” playwright Paula Vogel has created a deeply personal play about life with her late mother, Phyllis Rita. She surely would have been delighted to be portrayed by no less than Jessica Lange, an actress fully capable of turning her into a boozy but sympathetic hybrid of Mama Rose in “Gypsy,” Joan Crawford in “Mommie Dearest” and Tennessee Williams’ Amanda Wingfield.

READ THE REVIEW