READ THE REVIEWS:

March 21, 2024

In building such a huge and heart-filling musical one image at a time, the creators of “Water for Elephants” have disproved the old circus adage behind the title, which holds that you can never deliver enough sustenance for a creature so large and thirsty. Apparently, you can.

READ THE REVIEW

March 22, 2024

Director Jessica Stone beautifully navigates the musical’s tricky order: execute the level of physical extravagance any circus-musical hybrid of this monumental scale demands, but keep Jacob’s potent, time-leaping personal story intact.

READ THE REVIEW

March 21, 2024

Step right up, come one, come all, ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls, step right up to the greatest—well, okay, not the greatest show on Broadway, but a dang fine show nonetheless.

READ THE REVIEW

March 21, 2024

Ultimately, Water proves to be a fairly disappointing choice by director Stone as a follow-up to the brilliant Kimberly Akimbo (but, really, what wouldn’t have been?). It’s modest pleasures are never anything but safe, even without a net.

READ THE REVIEW

March 21, 2024

If, like me, you are highly susceptible to sawdust and tinsel, then much of Water for Elephants will delight on the basis of spectacle alone — and that’s okay.

READ THE REVIEW
Entertainment Weekly
BigThumbs_MEH

Shania
Russell

March 21, 2024

If nothing else, we never wonder how Jacob is swept away by the circus. The romance may fall short, and the songs lack a certain luster, but the magic of the circus is winning.

READ THE REVIEW

March 21, 2024

“Water” has more exuberance than wit; more catchphrases than character.

READ THE REVIEW
New York Daily News
BigThumbs_UP

Chris
Jones

March 21, 2024

Here, by blending the worlds of Broadway and the not-so-big top, a tent always in danger of collapse, Stone captures a milieu that has slipped away from many hands.

READ THE REVIEW
Wall Street Journal
BigThumbs_MEH

Charles
Isherwood

March 21, 2024

Time was, when a dreamy kid felt oppressed, the allure of running away to join the circus would fire the imagination. An American myth, or sentimental lore, probably. But in the new musical “Water for Elephants,” ostensibly set in a seedy, second-rate circus, running off to join the crew would seem to be little more rebellious than joining an unusually boisterous Boy Scout troop.

READ THE REVIEW

March 21, 2024

Water for Elephants isn’t just the frontrunner for the 2024 Tony Award for Best Musical, it’s a bold assertion that this still young artform has plenty of tricks left to reveal. It may not be the greatest show on Earth, but it is most certainly the best new musical on Broadway.

READ THE REVIEW

March 21, 2024

Disney Theatricals can let out a sigh of relief. Its “Lion King” franchise on cute animal puppets is safe. Very safe.

READ THE REVIEW

March 21, 2024

But PigPen’s score, period appropriate with strumming ukuleles and happy-go-lucky lyrics, creates a strong thread to tie together the production’s tendency to roam. And the ensemble — by far the best arms on Broadway — provides endless visual richness. You’re never supposed to look too closely at the circus but, here, there’s more than enough to keep you staring.

READ THE REVIEW
New York Theatre Guide
BigThumbs_UP

Joe
Dziemianowicz

March 21, 2024

On paper, it’s straightforward rom-dram stuff. On stage at the Imperial Theatre, everything ascends thanks to its energizing and poetic elements. Jacob’s story unfurls amid legit acts – acrobats, daredevils, trapeze swingers, and more – that add a different dimension.

READ THE REVIEW

March 21, 2024

This underdog circus troupe may promote its entertainment as “Benzini Brothers’ Most Spectacular Show on Earth,” but for this rube’s nickels, “Water for Elephants” could be the greatest show on Broadway.

READ THE REVIEW