READ THE REVIEWS:

November 21, 2022

Never appearing without purpose, Mays seems to occupy every inch of the performance space and populates the place as an ensemble consisting of himself. In contrast to the narrator’s engaging presence, for instance, was Scrooge’s palpable loneliness, which made me take pause and contemplate it with a new understanding.

READ THE REVIEW

November 21, 2022

This “Carol” is a breathless entertainment. Is breathing such a bad thing? It might have been nice to have had more respite to appreciate Mays’s closefisted Scrooge, his liberal Cratchit and sweet Fan.

READ THE REVIEW

November 21, 2022

Truncation is the only alteration to Dickens’ tale here, which Mays both narrates and occupies. The result is a theatrically ambitious but utterly aimless offering of holiday bah humbug.

READ THE REVIEW

November 21, 2022

There are more than the usual number of miracles to be observed with the latest version of A Christmas Carol to hit Broadway.

READ THE REVIEW

November 21, 2022

Playing both narrator and all the characters is no small feat—as the warm standing ovation for Mays showed at the end, the night this critic attended, reflected. But the magic of this production, adapted by Mays, Susan Lyons, and director Michael Arden, is just as much to do with the Laffrey’s stupendous stage design, which is a riot of trickery and surprises, Ben Stanton’s lighting, and Joshua D. Reid’s sound design.

READ THE REVIEW

November 21, 2022

That opening line always gives me the chills, and never more so than in this one-man (plus spooky specter) show featuring that consummate artist of many voices and lightning-quick changes, Jefferson Mays.

READ THE REVIEW

November 21, 2022

No two actors could achieve what Mays, Stanton and Arden offer up here: the suddenly meek and frightened Scrooge bathed in warm candle light one minute, the commanding and devouring Marley drenched in green stench only a second later. How can any “Christmas Carol” ever top that kind of theatrical tour de force?

READ THE REVIEW

November 21, 2022

To you, dear reader, I would offer that you have never seen a Christmas Carol quite like the one now running on Broadway at the Nederlander Theatre, and that if you see only one version of Dickens’s classic tale this season, this should be it.

READ THE REVIEW
New York Daily News
BigThumbs_UP

Chris
Jones

November 21, 2022

Nothing wrong with a good shudder at the holidays. Gets you in practice for the new year.

READ THE REVIEW

November 21, 2022

What’s so striking about this streamlined “Carol,” though, is the grandeur it manages to summon with simplicity — and how brisk the show is in every sense of the word.

READ THE REVIEW
New York Theatre Guide
BigThumbs_UP

Joe
Dziemianowicz

November 21, 2022

It’s easy to get a little humbug: Another holiday season, another take on A Christmas Carol. Like other theatrical versions of the classic, this one ends with the same words credited to Tiny Tim – “God bless us, everyone.” But a production this taut and well-told is its own sort of blessing.

READ THE REVIEW

November 21, 2022

It’s a thrilling start which suggests a fright-tastic, horror theater approach to Charles Dickens’s oft-theatricalized 1843 novella. Only for 30 or so spine-tingling minutes does this new adaptation, co-conceived by director Michael Arden and scenic/costume designer Dane Laffrey, live up to that promise.

READ THE REVIEW