READ THE REVIEWS:

September 29, 2024

“The Hills of California” is a yarn, not a lesson; a tale, not a tract. It resists interpretation, possibly as a way of resisting criticism, which, despite its flaws, it clearly does with great success.

READ THE REVIEW

September 30, 2024

In the British playwright’s expert hands, the nearly three-hour tragicomedy never feels indulgent; the rich texture of the world Butterworth builds is our payoff.

READ THE REVIEW

September 29, 2024

It’s in that long, almost serialized air that Hills best breathes: when, as in a soap, your attention is enthralled by the bigger picture.

READ THE REVIEW

September 29, 2024

The Hills of California is often very funny, but it has a core of deep regret that gets revealed as layers of family secrets are peeled away.

READ THE REVIEW

September 29, 2024

The sheer exuberant maximalism of The Ferryman went a long way toward obscuring, even at times absolving, the show’s overdependence on some pretty trite types and twists. In The Hills of California, Butterworth’s calculations are exposed. He’s cooking with the same stock, but the soup has gotten unappetizingly thin.

READ THE REVIEW

September 29, 2024

The Broadway mounting also benefits from the virtue of time. You can tell that 10 of the actors (including the four adult sisters and their younger counterparts) have been doing the play for six months already, and their performances are now detailed and lived-in. They’re aided by Howell’s costumes (which perfectly establish period and social status), chilling lighting from Natasha Chivers, and positively ghostly sound design by Nick Powell.

READ THE REVIEW
New York Theatre Guide
BigThumbs_MEH

Allison
Considine

September 29, 2024

Ultimately, it is the cast that makes the Seaview memorable. The play is a true ensemble showcase, with the adult sisters and their younger counterparts hitting all the stops… Butterworth’s portrayal of grief and the memories people choose to remember — and forget — is moving, and worth checking into the Seaview (the Broadhurst Theatre) to experience.

READ THE REVIEW

September 29, 2024

“A superbly performed reckoning with old traumas and those family squabbles that can seem so petty on the surface.”

READ THE REVIEW

September 29, 2024

That’s not to say that family dynamics like these aren’t worth further examination, or that Butterworth’s take on them isn’t artfully done. But almost nothing about it feels original.

READ THE REVIEW

September 29, 2024

It’s not the playwright’s best (that’s “Jerusalem,” which Mark Rylance was explosive in on Broadway) or his grandest (that’d be “The Ferryman”). But “Hills” has an appealing haunted atmosphere, even if the ghosts aren’t specters, but traumas. And in its dreamy third act, the play distinguishes itself from the many, many dramas about kids caught in the web of their parent’s pipe dream.

READ THE REVIEW

September 29, 2024

Jez Butterworth’s ambitious, captivating and richly rewarding domestic drama “The Hills of California” straddles dual worlds of dreams and reality as it shuttles between two pivotal time periods in the lives of the Webb women.

READ THE REVIEW

September 29, 2024

The Hills of California is a sludgy drag in which not enough happens, and not enough familial depth and grit examined, to merit such a long performance. If one had a brutal red pen in hand, the first act could be scythed completely; the play would rattle along better at just under two hours.

READ THE REVIEW
Entertainment Weekly
BigThumbs_UP

Dalton
Ross

September 29, 2024

The Hills of California does not necessarily venture to any places that dysfunctional family drama has not tread before, but the switching-back-and-forth-between-decades structure — coupled with a commanding and versatile centerpiece performance by Donnelly — still make these hills worth climbing.

READ THE REVIEW

September 29, 2024

Sam Mendes’ direction delivers that stunning moment by making perfect use of Rob Howell’s cold, spooky and monumental set. In addition to giving us Donnelly’s great performance, Mendes makes us believe the four adolescent actors are real sisters.

READ THE REVIEW