READ THE REVIEWS:

November 16, 2026

But the real reason this Second Stage production of “The Fantasticks,” directed and choreographed by Christopher Gattelli, is such an outlier among current Broadway musicals is that it is bereft of the slightest hint of sarcasm, power belting or video trickery. The show basks in quaintness and the magic of traditional theater-making, with its supporting players, expertly portrayed by David Patrick Kelly and Kevin Del Aguila, forming a kind of connective tissue to Shakespeare and vaudeville.

READ THE REVIEW

November 16, 2026

It begs the question, can a show as modest and of its time as The Fantasticks retain its purity alongside the likes of Wicked, Hamilton, and Dolly: A True Musical Story? The answer is a resounding yes in the hands of director Christopher Gattelli and an all-around heavenly cast. This production for Second Stage at the Helen Hayes Theater is loving and uncynical, a sweet little gem that doesn’t try to be something it’s not by virtue of location.

READ THE REVIEW

November 16, 2026

They, and everything else in this production, work together to bring a theatrical warhorse galloping into 21st Century Broadway, surprising us with just how much pluck it can still carry.

READ THE REVIEW

November 16, 2026

The charming new Broadway incarnation of The Fantasticks, lovingly directed and choreographed by Christopher Gattelli, has roots in the show’s storied past; Jason Sherwood’s set begins with a ghost-lit evocation of the original Off Broadway run. But it plants itself firmly in the present, and comes to unexpected bloom.

READ THE REVIEW
The Guardian
BigThumbs_UP

Richard
Lawson

November 16, 2026

It’s a Fantasticks for the longtime fans, and a warm invitation to the uninitiated to forgive its slight corniness and succumb to its gentle charms.

READ THE REVIEW

November 16, 2026

This first Broadway revival of “The Fantasticks” is blessed with great singing voices and Nevin Steinberg’s amplification supports them without homogenizing those voices into the current loud-arena sound design that infects the rest of Broadway.

READ THE REVIEW
Usa Today
BigThumbs_UP

Patrick
Ryan

November 16, 2026

Every so often, there’s a musical that reminds you just how heavenly a night of theater can be… At a moment when so many Broadway shows are crutched by insipid star casting and overblown vocal gymnastics, Christopher Gattelli’s sublime and heart-tugging revival feels like an antidote to an industry that’s increasingly allergic to simple, earnest storytelling.

READ THE REVIEW
New York Theatre Guide
BigThumbs_MEH

Joe
Dziemianowicz

November 16, 2026

The rest of The Fantasticks doesn’t rise quite so high, but there’s more to like in this beautifully sung version of book writer/lyricist Tom Jones and composer Harvey Schmidt’s 66-year-old musical making its Broadway debut. The show arrives at the Hayes Theater with bragging rights as the world’s longest-running musical and hummable hits like “Try to Remember,” “Soon It’s Gonna Rain,” and “They Were You.” The show also arrives with its imperfections.

READ THE REVIEW
New York Daily News
BigThumbs_UP

Chris
Jones

November 16, 2026

Apropos of that, it’s probably a high compliment to say, if you liked “The Fantasticks” in its original form, then you will like this one, too. (The reverse might also be true). That’s because the director, Christopher Gattelli, manages to make this switch to two boys and their mothers not only feel like the most natural thing in the world but also as if the show originally was penned that way.

READ THE REVIEW
New York Stage Review
BigThumbs_UP

Melissa Rose
Bernardo

November 16, 2026

Truthfully, the gender swap has been done so seamlessly that a Fantasticks newbie would never know the pair previously had been Matt and Luisa. The structure and soul of the show remain untouched—it’s still a sweet little story about two naive young lovers, their madcap hopes and dreams, and the harsh realities that bring them back to earth.

READ THE REVIEW
New York Stage Review
BigThumbs_MEH

David
Finkle

November 16, 2026

But does this Jones revision maintain the original clarity? The applicable word is “overdone.” With this renewed gander at The Fantasticks the question continues to be: Can’t audiences be trusted to get the clear point? The auxiliary question continues to be: Must today’s audiences be coddled with the excessive? If the answer to both queries is yes, then more’s the pity.

READ THE REVIEW
Culture Sauce
BigThumbs_UP

Thom
Geier

November 16, 2026

You’d have to be a hard-hearted cynic yourself to resist the charms of The Fantasticks. This artfully staged revival conjures a nostalgia for plain storytelling, elegant folk melodies with a hint of classicism, and unembellished romanticism — all in a still somewhat intimate setting. No flying witches or swooping vampires or American patriots on spinning turntables. Sometimes all you need is a bell and a whistle — or, in this case, a piano and a harp — to create musical magic.

READ THE REVIEW