READ THE REVIEWS:

December 22, 2024

A talented cast has fun in Simon Rich’s Broadway debut, but the minimally staged show doesn’t quite justify the hefty price of tickets.

READ THE REVIEW

December 22, 2024

It’s got a simple center, with some fun and some heart to it, but the commercial stunt of the whole endeavor is pointed and unavoidable.

READ THE REVIEW

December 22, 2024

The 90-minute All In is a perfect holiday snickerdoodle, a light and tasty snack no less funny for its brevity and lack of splashy production values.

READ THE REVIEW

December 22, 2024

Ticket-buyers are being charged as much as $800 a pop some weeks for what is little more than a sedate staged reading of New Yorker cartoon captions uttered by celebrities.

READ THE REVIEW

December 22, 2024

“All In” brings a different kind of comedy to the stage, a gentler kind of wit, packaged at a modest length and in a minimalist form, though elegantly staged by Alex Timbers and designed by a theatrical A-team.

READ THE REVIEW

December 22, 2024

All In may not be a full dramatic meal, but it’s a tasty treat for the run-up to Valentine’s Day, sweet and tart as a candy heart.

READ THE REVIEW

December 22, 2024

I have to say that I was smiling throughout much of the show, but with the exceptions of one or two winners, All In feels like a joke that goes on for too long and it doesn’t have the knee-slapping payoff to make it worth 90 minutes of your time.

READ THE REVIEW
New York Theatre Guide
BigThumbs_MEH

Caroline
Cao

December 22, 2024

Theatricality can be spun out of minimal blocking as the actors gesture and emote from their seats, but All In remains limited as a conceptual presentation rather than a fully realized theatrical event.

READ THE REVIEW
New York Stage Review
BigThumbs_MEH

David
Finkle

December 22, 2024

Many of those around me were laughing, yes, though never guffawing, never delivering the sorts of belly laughs that often elicit yet increased communal laughter.

READ THE REVIEW
New York Stage Review
BigThumbs_MEH

Frank
Scheck

December 22, 2024

It’s all very cozy, like a reading at your favorite independent bookstore, except that the Hudson is a large theater and, with the exception of benefits, audiences don’t generally pay hundreds of dollars to attend readings.

READ THE REVIEW
New York Sun
BigThumbs_UP

Elysa
Gardner

December 22, 2024

Varying in length from short and sweet to overextended, they’re literate, irreverent, and goofy in that knowing way one associates with the kind of bright, impeccably educated young men (and sometimes women) who find success writing for late-night television shows and prestigious magazines.

READ THE REVIEW