In ‘John Proctor Is the Villain,’ It’s the Girls vs. the Men

Taymor’s production is entirely sympathetic — to the characters and to the text. Though thrilling in its refusal to tamp down the show’s sometimes anarchic spirit, it does not ignore the dangers of abandon. Sink’s Shelby is beautifully positioned just at the spot where you can’t tell the difference between impulse and illness. The other girls stratify at in-between altitudes, from Scott’s firmly grounded Nell to Strazza’s high-pitched Beth.