READ THE REVIEWS:

September 19, 2008

So much for all those satisfyingly cheap jokes a critic might have been making this morning about “A Tale of Two Cities," the lumpish musical adaptation of the beloved Charles Dickens novel, which opened on Thursday at the Al Hirschfeld Theater.

READ THE REVIEW
Newsday
BigThumbs_MEH

April 22, 2014

A Tale of Two Cities" is a middling Masterpiece Musical, a paint-by-numbers throwback to the late – and, in this corner, unlamented – heyday of novelized epics on turntables. It has lots of nice period costumes and good actors singing their lungs inside out on material that all sounds the same.

READ THE REVIEW
AM NEW YORK BigThumbs_DOWN

April 22, 2014

The pre-Broadway buzz surrounding "A Tale of Two Cities" had nothing to do with Charles Dickens. Its lead actor, James Barbour, got caught up in a sticky, scandalous legal quagmire that we’d rather not describe yet again. But regardless of his controversial and criminal past, Barbour is the best asset of this otherwise awful musical.

READ THE REVIEW
Broadwayspace.com
BigThumbs_UP

April 22, 2014

READ THE REVIEW
Usa Today
BigThumbs_DOWN

April 22, 2014

Do you think Les Miserables stands as the greatest accomplishment in the history of musical theater? Would you argue that the musical version of Jane Eyre that plodded onto Broadway in 2000 never got the respect it deserved?

READ THE REVIEW

April 22, 2014

With flags waving high, the thunder of timpani and a cast of 35 powerful voices staring off into the distance and singing that “it won’t be long until tomorrow is today,” fans of big, robust period costume musicals (a la Les Misérables and The Scarlet Pimpernel) are likely to be utterly enraptured with "A Tale of Two Cities". Borrowing more than a page from its lucrative predecessors, "Tale" succeeds as a rousing crowd-pleaser with vibrant harmonies, intricate lighting and an elaborate multi-level set.

READ THE REVIEW
THEATERMANIA

April 22, 2014

When word got around that daily changes were being made to the new tuner A Tale of Two Cities, a waggish friend of mine said, "Maybe they’re adding a third city." They haven’t, but first-time composer-lyricist-librettist Jill Santoriello and her colleagues still needed to do something radical to raise their blatant attempt at cloningLes Miserables above the level of Anglo-Gallic mediocrity that now appears on the stage of the Al Hirschfeld Theatre.

READ THE REVIEW
Associated Press

April 22, 2014

Haven’t we been here before? And in much better crafted company?.

READ THE REVIEW
Ny1

April 22, 2014

The similarities between the new musical “A Tale of Two Cities” and "Les Miserables" are unmistakable. From the moment the first chords are struck, you may get the sense you’ve heard it all before.

READ THE REVIEW